Good  Shepherd  
Lutheran Church

Good Shepherd Church

 Return to Pastor’s Sermons Page

“Herod, Why this Senseless Fear?”

Rev. David K. Groth

December 30, 2007

 

 

“When Herod realized that he had been outwitted by the Magi, he was furious, and he gave orders to kill all the boys in Bethlehem and its vicinity who were two years old and under” (Mt. 2:16).

 

                The Bible is about real people in real places.  You can check the historicity, the reliability of the biblical record against secular resources, and when you do, you learn the biblical record is very reliable.  There’s geography in the Bible.  Many of the world’s religions, such as Hinduism, do not have geography.  The Book of Mormon mentions a lot of geographical place names, but none of them have been found.  In the Old Testament, 92% of the places named have been identified.  98% of the places in the New Testament have been identified.  100% of the locations in Luke have been identified.

                The field of archaeology is also verifying the reliability of the biblical record.  For a long time, scholars were claiming Pontius Pilate, for example, was a mythical person, no more real than a unicorn or Zeus.  But then, Pilate’s name started showing up, in the ancient records the Romans kept on their governors and ancient Jewish records that they kept.  His name was even carved into stone, a building he commissioned.  

                Christians often assume that all religious systems have a good degree of reliability.  That’s simply not true.  The events of the Bible happened in real places in real time to real people; they didn’t happen inside the head of Buddha or Joseph Smith. 

                All this, by way of introduction, is to say we actually know quite a lot about this Herod in our text, and much of it comes from secular historians.   Herod was not a Jew.  He represented the occupiers of the land, the Romans.  He was appointed King of Judea by the Roman Senate.  His service began in 47 B.C. and ended shortly after the birth of Christ.  He was known as Herod the Great, and in many ways he earned the title.  He was a great builder.  He constructed the mammoth harbor in Caesarea.  He constructed a number of huge fortresses.  He brought Roman entertainment to Judea, building theaters, amphitheaters.  He could even be generous, dramatically cutting taxes to make things easier for the people during the famine of 25 B.C. 

But historians say Herod had a terrible flaw to his character:  he was suspicious, paranoid, and in his latter years, this paranoia ran the show.  He was utterly convinced that others were after his throne.  And he had reason to think this.  Dr. Paul Maier, professor of ancient history at Western Michigan University, wrote, “Herod’s 10 wives had borne a wriggling, ambitious brood of sons, who turned the Jerusalem palace into a human can of worms in their scheming to succeed him” (Luth. Wit. Jan, ’94). 

Herod’s paranoia got the better of him.  He suspected family members of treason and promptly eliminated them, including one of his wives and her mother; his uncle and three of his sons; Antipater, Alexander and Aristobulus.  The Roman Emperor at the time, Caesar Augustus, said “it is safer to be Herod’s pig than Herod’s son.”   

From his deathbed, Herod ordered the most distinguished citizens of the country be arrested on trumped up charges and imprisoned in the great hippodrome of Jericho, an oval shaped stadium used for horse and chariot races.  The moment he died, archers were to massacre these hundreds. The reason? Herod knew that when he died few would grieve and many would celebrate.  He would give the country something to cry about. 

Historians know Herod as a sick, scheming, paranoid murderous old man.  This is the man whose life intersects with that of God’s Son, Jesus.  We know there’s trouble ahead, when the magi, the wise men, come in search of Jesus.  In Jerusalem, they start asking around, “Where is the one who has been born king of the Jews.”  Herod hears word of this and thinks, “I’m the king around here.”  To him, their question sounds like, “Where’s the new born king, you has been?”  or “Where’s the real king, you fraud?”  Matthew writes, “When King Herod heard this he was disturbed, and all Jerusalem with him.”  They were distressed because they knew what Herod was capable of. 

                Herod summons the religious elite of Jerusalem.  That is, he calls for a meeting of the Sanhedrin.  He asks them “where is the Christ supposed to be born?”  They answer, “In Bethlehem of Judea” showing him chapter and verse from the prophet Micah.  And so Herod hatches a plan to have the Magi locate the baby for him, so that, quote, “I too may go and worship him.”  Herod sounds so sincere, doesn’t he, so spiritual, so religious!  All he wants to do is bow down and worship Jesus too.  But we know what the Magi don’t.  Herod has no intentions to worship anyone.  Herod’s paranoia is calling the shots again; he’s stirring up a plan to destroy Jesus.

                The magi start for Bethlehem, the star leading the way. Eventually, they find Jesus; he’s in a house now, no longer in the manger.  Apparently Joseph found better accommodations for his family. They worship Jesus.  Then they present their gifts of gold, frankincense, and myrrh, the kind of gifts one gives to kings, the kind of gifts that were most valuable, transportable and marketable in that day, ideal for sustaining Mary and Joseph in another country.  Later, the magi are warned in a dream not to return to Herod.  Joseph is also warned in a dream, “Get up now and escape to Egypt.”

                Herod eventually figures out he’s been duped and he is furious.  When ever Herod gets mad, people die.  Herod orders that all males, two years old and younger in Bethlehem be slaughtered, assuming Jesus will be among them. Based on the evidence, it is believed there could hardly have been more than a thousand inhabitants in Bethlehem at the time, which means about 20-25 children of that age in Bethlehem, half of which are the wrong sex.  So about twelve little boys are murdered that day by Roman soldiers.  We must not exaggerate the number, as has been done in the past, but a smaller number makes the act no less wicked. They are the first to be killed because of Jesus, the first of many martyrs.  We don’t even know their names.   

                This is the world into which Jesus is born, and Matthew will not allow us to forget it or ignore it.  There is evil in this world.  Not just people who do evil things; not just soldiers who follow orders.  There is raw evil in the world, and a prince of evil who inspires wicked acts great and small within each of us.  And there is good in the world, not just people who do good things, but a God who is good.  And the two are at war.

This is the world into which Jesus was born.  It’s a world where there is senseless death, a world where innocent children lose their lives because even well-dressed, polished and respectable people are capable of wicked acts.  It’s a world where civilians, including women and children, are considered “soft targets,” a world where any idiot who manages to detonate a bomb is given the title of “mastermind” in our newspapers.  It’s a world where the tongue is capable of praise one minute and of malicious slander the next.  We would prefer to hide this behind the soft candlelight glow of Christmas Eve, yet Matthew insists we remember the man capable of good, but also great evil, and the little children he murdered.

There’s really only one more thing I want to say of Herod.  He’s still on the loose. The world still thinks of Jesus as a threat. Even we, who so recently celebrated the birth of Jesus, even we have a little Herod within our hearts. We usually call it the old Adam, but today it may help to think of him as Herod.

The Herod who sits on the throne of our hearts sees in Jesus one who would interfere with our lives, our choices, our ambitions.  We don’t want to recognize another king in our own little kingdom.  We don’t want to have answer to him.  We don’t want to have to follow this Jesus.  By nature, we don’t even want him to get too close.  He might turn our priorities upside down.  He might find there are better things we can do with our time, our money, our skills.  He might find some of our behaviors unacceptable.  He might tell us to change some things about us, things we don’t want to change.  I had a professor who said once, “Let the camel’s nose in the tent, and pretty soon the whole beast will be forcing his way in.”  So it is with Jesus.  Best keep him outside.

                Herod was hostile toward God, but so is the sinful mind.  That is to say, there is still lurking within us a sinister Old Man who has the urge to banish God from our hearts, the malicious desire to send God off into exile again, all the way to Egypt if necessary.

                We would prefer not to remember this part of the Christmas story, at least not so close to Christmas, but Matthew believes it’s important that we do, because Jesus was born into a real Bethlehem, an inhospitable and dangerous place.  The Scriptures teach that our hearts are just as inhospitable and dangerous to Jesus as was old Bethlehem.  We should be giving him the finest room in the house, together with the first fruits of our offerings.  As it is, he’ll have to make do with the shed out back, and perhaps some scraps from our table.  (Too often we treat the Lord God Almighty as if he were a common barn cat!)   

                The Good News is Jesus will take what he can get.  He’s not picky in that way. 

He was born in and for the real world and real people. Jesus was born into this world not in spite of the Herods and their wickedness, but precisely because of them.  And he doesn’t have in mind to take over the kingdoms of this world.  He has in mind the salvation of this world.  This one bound so tightly by swaddling cloths will loosen the grip of sin and death on us, and in turn, bind the strong man.  So the old Christmas carol says,

 

“This little Babe so few days old,

Is come to rifle Satan’s fold;

All hell doth at His presence quake,

Though He Himself for cold do shake.”

                  

                “Herod, why this senseless fear?” another hymn asks.  He’s not after your throne; he’s after, your heart.  And though Jesus will be spared the Roman sword in Bethlehem, he will not be spared the Roman cross outside Jerusalem.  We praise God for that.  That’s why he was born.  That’s love in a real world.  Amen.

 


 

 

 

Return to top of page

Copyright © 2004-2008

Good Shepherd Lutheran Church & School

1611 E Main Street

Watertown, WI  53094

 

Church Office hours:

Monday thru Friday 7:30  to 3:30 PM

Phone: 920-261-2570

Fax:  920-261-2769

 

If you have any comments or problems

with this web site please email the

Webmaster